Constance spoke next.
“If you don’t say it, the judge will make you stay with a mother who can’t take care of you. Then Daddy won’t be able to see you. Is that what you want? Do you want Daddy to go away?”
On the video, nothing moved except a shadow crossing the carpet.
Then came the sound of a child trying not to cry.
“No.”
“Then say it,” Constance told her. “Mommy hit me.”
“Mommy hit me,” Penny repeated.
A sound escaped me before I could stop it. Ms. Alvarez sat rigid beside Penny. Judge Whitfield’s pen, which had been moving across her notes, came to rest against the page.
Russell stared straight ahead.
The first clip ended. Before anyone could speak, a second file began.
The angle was the same, but the timestamp had changed to October 19. I could see a pair of Brianna’s shoes near the couch.
Her voice came through the monitor, casual and amused.
“The accountant is going to be a problem. She was always sniffing around the books.”
“She can’t prove anything,” Russell replied. “She hasn’t worked in years. By the time she understands what she’s looking at, I’ll have custody. She’ll be too busy trying to see her kid to fight me over money.”
I looked at the folder on my table. For weeks I had wondered whether the offshore account and the custody petition were connected or whether I was imposing one betrayal onto another.
Russell answered that question in his own voice.
Brianna asked, “What about the Nevis account?”
“It’s in my mother’s maiden name. I’m not an idiot. Once Meredith is declared unstable, nobody listens to her. Judges love a father with a clean house and a crying kid.”
He laughed briefly.
Constance’s voice followed from somewhere near the camera.
“Penny is very convincing when she cries. We only have to keep her scared enough.”
The monitor went black.
For several seconds, the only sound was the courtroom ventilation system.
I turned toward Russell. His skin had taken on a gray cast that made his wedding suit look almost black by comparison. His mouth opened slightly, but no explanation came.
Constance’s hand had closed around her pearls. Brianna kept her gaze on the table, the diamond bracelet now hidden beneath her other hand.
Mr. Prescott moved half a step away from his client.
“Your Honor,” he said with great care, “I request a recess to confer with Mr. Calloway.”
“I understand why you would,” Judge Whitfield said. “Not yet.”
She turned to Penny.
“May I ask you a question?”
Penny nodded.
“Did your mother ever hit you?”
“No, ma’am. Never.”