The Table They Chose
The smallest girl had both arms wrapped around my leg when she looked up from beneath the café table and whispered, “Pretend you’re our father.”
I had been alone with a pot of tea, expecting an uneventful hour before returning to my office. The café on Wabash Avenue was busy enough that no one paid attention when the first child slipped beneath the white tablecloth. I almost thought I had imagined her. Then a second face appeared, followed by a third and a fourth.
All four girls wore matching navy coats and cream-colored ribbons. Their expressions did not match at all. The oldest looked furious in the determined way children do when anger is the only thing holding fear back. Another watched the entrance with wide, alert eyes. The third seemed close to tears. The smallest had attached herself to my pant leg as if I were the last fixed object in a moving room.
“Please,” she said again.
Most people in Chicago knew better than to crawl under Alexander Hayes’s table.
My name carried the kind of reputation that made strangers lower their voices. Behind respectable office doors, I controlled businesses, territory, information, and men who understood that disloyalty came with consequences. I had spent years learning how fear changed a person’s breathing, posture, and judgment.
Fear in a child was different. It had no strategy. It simply looked for somewhere safe to go.
I lowered my teacup. “Are you lost?”
Four heads shook.
The smallest glanced toward the entrance and tightened her arms around me.
“Our mom is over there.”
I followed her gaze. A woman in a charcoal-gray suit stood near the door with two men. Her dark auburn hair was pinned neatly behind her head. She held herself with elegance, but her eyes were moving over the room too quickly. She was not socializing. She was searching.
“Then you should go to her,” I said.
“No.”
All four answered at once.
I leaned back enough to see them clearly. “Why not?”
The oldest looked at the others before answering. “Mr. Mercer is with her.”
“Which one is Mr. Mercer?”
She pointed toward the taller man beside their mother. He wore a dark suit and the comfortable smile of someone who assumed rooms would make space for him.
“What did he do?” I asked.
One girl swallowed. “He told Mommy she was difficult.”
Another spoke so quietly I had to bend closer. “He said nobody trusts women who can’t keep a husband.”
“He says our family looks broken,” the third added.
The smallest kept her eyes on me. “And he said he could fix us.”
I felt something in my chest tighten.
“Did he hurt you?”
They shook their heads.
“Did he threaten you?”
This time, the answer did not come immediately. The girls looked at one another, deciding how much an adult stranger could be trusted with.
Finally, the oldest said, “He told Mommy she would marry him eventually.”
“He said we should start calling him Dad,” another whispered.
“Do you want to?”